2 Adults

Compare other sites

Filters

Star Ratings

5
19
52
31
6
Unrated29

Price (per night)

$0 - $502
$50 - $10015
$100 - $1509
$150 - $20017
$200+99

Review Score

Superb 9+34
Very Good 8+27
Good 7+21
Pleasant 6+17

Property Type

Hotel52
Bed & Breakfast35
Inn20
Motel17
Resort8
Guest House4
Vacation Rental4
Apartment2

Hotel Facilities

Wi-Fi105
Swimming pool57
Garden47
24-Hour reception39
Room service27
Spa18
Concierge18
Pet friendly17
Elevator / Lift17
Bicycle rental13
Private beach13
Fitness center13
Restaurant12
Parking8
Babysitting8
Disabled access6
Bar5
Child pool2
Airport shuttle1
Allergy-free rooms1
Outdoor heated pool1
Cafeteria1

Room Facilities

Air conditioning88
TV28
Safe-deposit box24
Refrigerator18
Hair dryer16
Coffee / Tea maker15
Kitchenette15
Microwave13
Bathrobes5
Mini Bar4
Bathtube2
Ice machine1
142 hotels
Sort by:
The Inn at Harbor Knoll
The Inn at Harbor KnollGreenport- Show on map
    Avg. price/night

    $432

    House on Chase Creek
    House on Chase CreekShelter Island Heights- Show on map

    Superb, 9.3

    (20reviews)
    • Room service
    • Garden
    • 24-Hour reception
    • Bicycle rental
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $128

    The Chequit
    The ChequitShelter Island Heights- Show on map

    Superb, 9.2

    (180reviews)
    • Garden
    • 24-Hour reception
    • Wi-Fi
    • Parking
    Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast
    Harbor Knoll Bed and BreakfastGreenport- Show on map
    • Swimming pool
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $476

    Sunset Beach
    Sunset BeachShelter Island Heights- Show on map

    6.0

    (133reviews)
    • Room service
    • Pet friendly
    • Private beach
    • Babysitting
    • Wi-Fi
    The Pridwin Hotel
    The Pridwin HotelShelter Island Heights- Show on map

    Good, 7.3

    (275reviews)
    • Bar
    • Swimming pool
    • Babysitting
    • Wi-Fi
    West Neck Guesthouse
    West Neck GuesthouseShelter Island Heights- Show on map

    Superb, 9.4

    (8reviews)
    • Room service
    • Garden
    • Wi-Fi
    Shelter Island House
    Shelter Island HouseShelter Island Heights- Show on map

    Fabulous, 8.7

    (25reviews)
    • Room service
    • Swimming pool
    • Spa
    • Garden
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $401

    The Harborfront Inn
    The Harborfront InnGreenport- Show on map

    Superb, 9.0

    (304reviews)
    • Room service
    • Swimming pool
    • Concierge
    • Elevator / Lift
    • 24-Hour reception
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $243

    The Menhaden Hotel
    The Menhaden HotelGreenport- Show on map
    • 24-Hour reception
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $441

    Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island
    Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter IslandShelter Island Heights- Show on map

    Exceptional, 9.9

    (94reviews)
    • Swimming pool
    • Garden
    • Bicycle rental
    • Parking
    Avg. price/night

    $382

    Greenporter Hotel
    Greenporter HotelGreenport- Show on map

    Very Good, 8.0

    (348reviews)
      Avg. price/night

      $199

      The Stirling House B&B Greenport
      The Stirling House B&B GreenportGreenport- Show on map

      Superb, 9.4

      (279reviews)
      • Garden
      • Concierge
      • Bicycle rental
      • Wi-Fi
      Avg. price/night

      $251

      Fordham House
      Fordham HouseGreenport- Show on map

      Exceptional, 10.0

      (235reviews)
      • Wi-Fi
      Townsend Manor Inn
      Townsend Manor InnGreenport- Show on map

      6.0

      (92reviews)
      • Restaurant
      • Swimming pool
      • Private beach
      • Child pool
      • Wi-Fi
      Avg. price/night

      $156

      American Beech Hotel
      American Beech HotelGreenport- Show on map

      Very Good, 8.3

      (53reviews)
      • Wi-Fi
      Avg. price/night

      $352

      Heron Suites at Port of Egypt Marine
      Heron Suites at Port of Egypt MarineSouthold- Show on map

      Very Good, 8.0

      (146reviews)
      • Swimming pool
      • Wi-Fi
      Avg. price/night

      $233

      Gallery Hotel Greenport
      Gallery Hotel GreenportGreenport- Show on map
      • Wi-Fi
      Avg. price/night

      $256

      The Cliffside Resort Condominiums
      The Cliffside Resort CondominiumsGreenport West- Show on map

      Very Good, 8.1

      (267reviews)
      • Pet friendly
      • Swimming pool
      • Private beach
      • Wi-Fi
      Avg. price/night

      $338

      Sound View Greenport
      Sound View GreenportSouthold- Show on map

      Very Good, 8.4

      (735reviews)
      • Restaurant
      • Fitness center
      • Swimming pool
      • Spa
      • Private beach
      • Wi-Fi
      • Parking
      Avg. price/night

      $280

      A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast
      A Walk in the Woods Bed and BreakfastSouthold- Show on map

      Very Good, 8.0

      (20reviews)
      • Bicycle rental
      • Wi-Fi
      Avg. price/night

      $301

      Shorecrest Bed and Breakfast
      Shorecrest Bed and BreakfastSouthold- Show on map

      Exceptional, 10.0

      (13reviews)
      • Pet friendly
      • Private beach
      • Garden
      • Concierge
      • Bicycle rental
      • Wi-Fi
      Avg. price/night

      $687

      The Blue Inn at North Fork
      The Blue Inn at North ForkEast Marion- Show on map

      Good, 7.5

      (69reviews)
      • Room service
      • Pet friendly
      • Disabled access
      • Swimming pool
      • Garden
      • Wi-Fi
      Quintessentials Bed and Breakfast and Spa
      Quintessentials Bed and Breakfast and SpaEast Marion- Show on map

      Exceptional, 10.0

      (150reviews)
      • Room service
      • Swimming pool
      • Spa
      • Garden
      • Concierge
      • Bicycle rental
      • Wi-Fi
      Southold Beach Motel
      Southold Beach MotelSouthold- Show on map

      6.8

      (80reviews)
      • Garden
      • Wi-Fi
      Avg. price/night

      $181

      Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast
      Arbor View House Bed and BreakfastEast Marion- Show on map

      Exceptional, 9.8

      (392reviews)
      • Spa
      • Garden
      • Concierge
      • Bicycle rental
      • Wi-Fi
      • Airport shuttle
      Avg. price/night

      $527

      1 of 5

      Loading...

      loading

      Best hotels in Shelter Island

      Trying to find hotel promo codes in Shelter Island? You are in a good place! Get ready for your journey to United States. There are astonishing places nearby Shelter Island including Manhanset Chapel, James Havens Homestead and Brecknock Hall. You trip won’t be complete if you don’t go there! You can use Groton-New London Airport which is situated 24 kilometers from the center of Shelter Island. We wish you enjoy your time in United States!

      Shelter Island has a wide range of accommodation as there are approximately 25 hotels closeby. If you are travelling on budget and need travel coupons be prepared to use DirectHotels.com! This hotel search platform is the best website which shows you all the best hotel vouchers. There’s nothing easier than using DirectHotels.com!

      How does it work?

      we study all the popular booking sites as well as hotel deals. If a hotel awards any kind of deals for booking directly they will be visible here! So, thanks to DirectHotels.com you can easily compare all the possibilities and choose the cheapest hotel.

      As we mentioned before there are a lot of possibilities in Shelter Island.

      Look at our favourite hotels in Shelter Island. Be ready for your journey to Shelter Island and remember that the best hotel deals you can find only on DirectHotels.com!