2 Adults

Compare other sites

Filters


Star Ratings

5
20
56
34
6
Unrated30

Price (per night)

$0 - $502
$50 - $10023
$100 - $15011
$150 - $20016
$200+99

Review Score

Superb 9+35
Very Good 8+30
Good 7+22
Pleasant 6+21

Property Type

Hotel61
Bed & Breakfast35
Inn21
Motel17
Resort7
Guest House4
Vacation Rental4
Apartment2

Hotel Facilities

Wi-Fi113
Swimming pool61
24-Hour reception49
Garden48
Room service30
Elevator / Lift22
Pet friendly20
Concierge19
Fitness center19
Spa18
Restaurant16
Bicycle rental13
Private beach12
Parking9
Babysitting8
Disabled access7
Bar5
Child pool2
Airport shuttle2
Cafeteria2
Allergy-free rooms1

Room Facilities

Air conditioning93
Safe-deposit box31
TV28
Refrigerator17
Hair dryer16
Coffee / Tea maker15
Kitchenette13
Microwave11
Bathrobes5
Mini Bar4
Bathtube2
Ice machine1

151 hotels
Sort by:
The Inn at Harbor Knoll
Avg. price/night

$432

The Menhaden Hotel
Avg. price/night

$441

Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast
Avg. price/night

$476

West Neck Guesthouse
West Neck GuesthouseShelter Island Heights- Show on map

Superb, 9.4

(8reviews)
  • Room service
  • Garden
  • Wi-Fi
Sunset Beach
Sunset BeachShelter Island Heights- Show on map

6.0

(133reviews)
  • Room service
  • Pet friendly
  • Private beach
  • Babysitting
  • Wi-Fi
The Harborfront Inn
The Harborfront InnGreenport- Show on map

Superb, 9.0

(304reviews)
  • Room service
  • Swimming pool
  • Concierge
  • Elevator / Lift
  • 24-Hour reception
  • Wi-Fi
Avg. price/night

$243

House on Chase Creek
House on Chase CreekShelter Island Heights- Show on map

Superb, 9.3

(20reviews)
  • Room service
  • Garden
  • 24-Hour reception
  • Bicycle rental
  • Wi-Fi
Avg. price/night

$128

Greenporter Hotel
Greenporter HotelGreenport- Show on map

Very Good, 8.0

(348reviews)
    Avg. price/night

    $199

    Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island
    Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter IslandShelter Island Heights- Show on map

    Exceptional, 9.9

    (94reviews)
    • Swimming pool
    • Garden
    • Bicycle rental
    • Parking
    Avg. price/night

    $382

    Shelter Island House
    Shelter Island HouseShelter Island Heights- Show on map

    Fabulous, 8.7

    (25reviews)
    • Room service
    • Swimming pool
    • Spa
    • Garden
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $401

    The Chequit
    The ChequitShelter Island Heights- Show on map

    Superb, 9.2

    (180reviews)
    • Garden
    • 24-Hour reception
    • Wi-Fi
    • Parking
    The Pridwin Hotel
    The Pridwin HotelShelter Island Heights- Show on map

    Good, 7.3

    (275reviews)
    • Bar
    • Swimming pool
    • Babysitting
    • Wi-Fi
    The Stirling House B&B Greenport
    The Stirling House B&B GreenportGreenport- Show on map

    Superb, 9.4

    (279reviews)
    • Garden
    • Concierge
    • Bicycle rental
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $251

    Sound View Greenport
    Sound View GreenportSouthold- Show on map

    Very Good, 8.4

    (735reviews)
    • Restaurant
    • Fitness center
    • Swimming pool
    • Spa
    • Private beach
    • Wi-Fi
    • Parking
    Avg. price/night

    $280

    American Beech Hotel
    American Beech HotelGreenport- Show on map

    Very Good, 8.3

    (53reviews)
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $352

    Townsend Manor Inn
    Townsend Manor InnGreenport- Show on map

    6.0

    (92reviews)
    • Restaurant
    • Swimming pool
    • Private beach
    • Child pool
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $156

    Heron Suites at Port of Egypt Marine
    Heron Suites at Port of Egypt MarineSouthold- Show on map

    Very Good, 8.0

    (146reviews)
    • Swimming pool
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $233

    The Blue Inn at North Fork
    The Blue Inn at North ForkEast Marion- Show on map

    Good, 7.5

    (69reviews)
    • Room service
    • Pet friendly
    • Disabled access
    • Swimming pool
    • Garden
    • Wi-Fi
    Southold Beach Motel
    Avg. price/night

    $181

    The Cliffside Resort Condominiums
    The Cliffside Resort CondominiumsGreenport West- Show on map

    Very Good, 8.1

    (267reviews)
    • Pet friendly
    • Swimming pool
    • Private beach
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $338

    Shorecrest Bed and Breakfast
    Shorecrest Bed and BreakfastSouthold- Show on map

    Exceptional, 10.0

    (13reviews)
    • Pet friendly
    • Private beach
    • Garden
    • Concierge
    • Bicycle rental
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $687

    Gallery Hotel Greenport
    Avg. price/night

    $256

    A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast
    A Walk in the Woods Bed and BreakfastSouthold- Show on map

    Very Good, 8.0

    (20reviews)
    • Bicycle rental
    • Wi-Fi
    Avg. price/night

    $301

    Fordham House
    Fordham HouseGreenport- Show on map

    Exceptional, 10.0

    (235reviews)
    • Wi-Fi
    Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast
    Arbor View House Bed and BreakfastEast Marion- Show on map

    Exceptional, 9.8

    (392reviews)
    • Spa
    • Garden
    • Concierge
    • Bicycle rental
    • Wi-Fi
    • Airport shuttle
    Avg. price/night

    $527

    Quintessentials Bed and Breakfast and Spa
    Quintessentials Bed and Breakfast and SpaEast Marion- Show on map

    Exceptional, 10.0

    (150reviews)
    • Room service
    • Swimming pool
    • Spa
    • Garden
    • Concierge
    • Bicycle rental
    • Wi-Fi

    1 of 6

    Loading...

    loading